Out of curiosity, over the weekend I compared
SoundHound and
Shazam to see which one is the superior music identification app for the iPhone; below are my results:
Install time:
Shazam was slightly faster
Identification time:
no significant difference
User Interface:
SoundHound seems to offer slightly more features, but Shazam has a clean UI
Identification Test (all songs tested were played over my laptop via Pandora):
Airstream Driver by
GomezSoundHound - identified the song/version/artist correctly
Shazam - failed first attempt; identified the song/version/artist correctly the second time
Hang 'Em High by
The Meters
SoundHound - identified the song/version/artist correctly
Shazam - identified the song/version/artist correctly
Hope She Falls In Love by
The Blue Dogs
SoundHound - failed to correctly identify the song/version/artist (tested twice)
Shazam - failed to correctly identify the song/version/artist (tested twice)
Hurricane Party (Live) by
James McMurty
SoundHound - identified the song/version/artist correctly
Shazam - identified the song/version/artist correctly
Come Talk To Me by
Get Busy Committee
SoundHound - failed first attempt; identified the song/version/artist incorrectly the second time as
Come
And Talk To Me (Remix)
by
Jodeci
Shazam - identified the song/version/artist incorrectly (tested twice; each time
Come And Talk To Me (Remix)
by
Jodeci
was identified
Artist Information:
Once the song/artist has been correctly identified, Shazam provides useful and readily accessible artist information (e.g. tour dates and Twitter/Facebook profile information), but SoundHound provides features Shazam does not, like a list of the albums the song has been featured on.
Price: Both offer trial versions where Shazam appears to allow 5 free
identifications per month, while SoundHound appears to only allow 5 total. Their paid versions both cost $4.99 and include unlimited music identifications. However, they should both
increase the number of identifications provided with their trial
versions to 10, as seemingly this would encourage use, which would probably lead
to higher purchase rates.
Conclusion:
It's a draw, as both seem to identify music equally, and both have difficulty identifying non-mainstream music (interesting to note that it was the same songs), so it's going to come down to your personal preference.
Recent Comments